By Liu Jianhui
Deputy Auditor General-CNAO
| The paper addresses the critical issue of an auditor being sensitive to security issues while Auditing in a Network environment and makes comments and practical suggestions in this regard. |
As a combination of network technology and audit, audit under a network
environment enjoys the advantage of open system interconnection, which
enables wide free share and flow of auditing information. As a result,
real time audit can be carried out dynamically through the network, so
as to examine and monitor the transactions of enterprises at every stage
and to make timely disclosures.
However, the network also makes it possible for information users to
take vicious actions to control, intercept, alter and even destroy the
information and resource data which will undoubtedly put audit work at
risk. Therefore, the security aspect of the network becomes the a key
factor while undertaking network-based audit.
1. Security requirements for network-based audit
In a network environment, security requirements include the reliability
and confidentiality of information used for audit, the safety of the
auditing system and the definitiveness of audit conclusion.
1.1 Reliability and confidentiality of the information used for audit
Material used in network-based audit generally exists in electronic
form which can be altered and forged without a trace, which reduces the
reliability of these materials. Besides, during the transmission process
in network, audit evidence is also subject to interception and
replacement and this undoubtedly puts the truthfulness of audit evidence
under threat.
Furthermore, since most of the information provided by the auditees
concerns business secrets, the interests of the auditees will be
severely undermined if the secrets are intercepted or duplicated during
the transmission process in network. Security, therefore, becomes an
essential requirement for audit in the network environment.
1.2 The safety of the auditing system
A large amount of data concerning the auditees’ business, such as
background materials and financial information, can be found in the
audit information database of the audit institution. Immeasurable losses
may occur if this data is altered, intercepted or embezzled. For this
reason, auditors should make sure that this data should not be
intercepted during the transmission process and that the audit data
processing system is free from unauthorized visits.
1.3 The definitiveness of the audit conclusions
Audit conclusions are the basis of many economic activities and their
veracity will not only directly affect the interests of auditees,
investors and customers but also the operation of banks, tax
authorities, industrial and commercial administration agencies. The
network is an open and public resource, through which the audit
conclusions drawn by audit institutions can be altered. Therefore,
maintaining the definitiveness of the audit conclusions is an
indispensable aspect of security.
2. Methods to guarantee the security of network-based audit
One major technical feature of network-based audit is the
transmission and processing of audit information. The security of audit
in network environment comprises two aspects: the security of the
computer network and that of the audit data processing system.
The security of a computer network embraces: computer network equipments
security, computer network system security, database security, network
protocols security and computer network management security etc. To
implement a network security reinforcement plan is therefore, important
for achieving security objectives of the network.
The audit data processing system security refers to the reliability of
the audit database and audit conclusions. The open and public nature of
the network demands a high level of security. To guarantee security, the
audit data processing system should possess the following functions: to
prevent the audit information being intercepted during the transmission
process, to prevent the audit database being accessed illegally, to
guarantee that accounting information cannot be forged and finally, to
ensure that the audit reports and conclusions are free from alteration.
2.1 To Establish a Certificate Authority System
As an indispensable condition for network-based audit, the system of
Certificate Authority is established to guarantee that only authorized
auditors can access relevant information in the auditee’s database and
use the information in his data processing system. The CA system ensures
that investors and customers can get correct and reliable audit
conclusions. For this purpose, an open and fair third-party
authentication authority is needed for issuing all kinds of digital
certificates and providing confirmation service.
2.2 Adopting data encryption techniques
Most of the data information collected in a network-based audit has a
prescription time and is transmitted via network, which should be
enciphered from plain text to cipher text. The encryption process
ensures that, even if the information were intercepted during the
transmission process, relevant secrets would not be leaked out.
2.3 Building a firewall for the audit data processing system
As the only guarded passage, a firewall examines all the information
in and out of the system, which means users of the audit data processing
system could control the security decision-making process in an
integrated way. According to different needs of customers for various
types of network, a firewall can enforce a set of comprehensive and
complicated security tactics. Furthermore, a firewall can also detect,
record and follow the tracks of the users’ activities and make further
analysis so as to protect network security.
2.4 Intrusion-detecting technology
Intrusion detection is a common network monitoring technique, and
also a very important approach to protect network security. First
introduced in 1985, the intrusion detection system is based on
statistical models and can actively prevent hackers from intruding the
network and avoiding incidents of “service denial” for legal users.
2.5 Protect audit trail
Audit trail refers to the information collected by analyzing codes,
balance sheets, and original transaction data generated during economic
activities in the accounting system. It is the auditee’s responsibility
to provide an intact audit trail. In an ‘audit under network
environment’, it is necessary not only to retain the audit evidence in
accounting management system but also to keep the audit trail of
transactions via network. To protect the audit trail existing in
electronic format, techniques of Certificate Authority, such as ‘digital
signature’ and ‘digital time seal’ could be adopted.
A mix of manual and half-manual audit methodology is still in vogue in
China, and the collection of audit evidence mainly depends on field
work. After being processed by computers, this evidence can be used in
the audit report. With the development of the network economy and
electronic business, network management will be improved greatly, which
serves as an impetus to the development of audit in the network
environment.